Autumn Sonata Revolution. After the revolution betrayed
By Ed Rampell
Bernardo Bertolucci’s 1964 film, Before the Revolution, was full of yearning for socialism. One would think that the collapse of Soviet-style socialism and the suppression of the 1989 Tienanmen Square protests in China would be fertile ground for filmmakers. In Mercedes Stalenhoef’s documentary Carmen Meets Borat, which was also screened at this year’s LAFF, the Romanian village’s capitalist -- of all people -- remarks in passing that the people were better off under communism. This, of course, is a great subject for a film, but few movies (at least those released in the West) have dealt with how the defeat of socialistic governments since the late 1980s have affected the masses of the Warsaw Pact nations, as well as socialists around the world. How do the true believers continue to live after their revolutionary god has failed them? How do they adjust to such cataclysmic change?
There have been notable exceptions to the neglect of this subject matter, such as the German films Go Trabi Go by Peter Timm and its 1992 sequel, plus Good Bye, Lenin, Wolfgang Becker’s witty 2003 satire. Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck’s The Lives of Others, about the so-called German Democratic Republic’s secret police spying on artists, won 2007’s Best Foreign Film Oscar.
Another German drama, Jan Schutte’s The Farewell – about Bertolt Brecht’s final days – had a similar theme; although the playwright died in 1958, The Farewell’s subject matter had contemporary relevance when it was released in 2000.
Now, a new Turkish film screened at LAFF joins the ranks of movie meditations on Marxism’s defeats in the past 20 years.
Writer-director Ozcan Alper’s somber Autumn is about Yusuf (sensitively played by Yusuf Onur Saylak), a political prisoner who, due to failing health, is finally released from prison after serving 10 years for his activism as a student radical. He returns home to his remote mountain village and aged mother. The world has moved on since his incarceration; his old comrades, such as his former girlfriend, have married and started families. The fall of the Berlin Wall (which had actually fallen before Yusuf’s imprisonment) has opened up travel opportunities for citizens of the former USSR, and now fallen women from what had been Soviet Georgia come to Turkey to ply their trade as the ultimate capitalists: prostitutes. Yusuf, who has been weakened by his decade-long incarceration, begins an affair with the beautiful if mournful hooker Eka (Megi Kobladaze), who has a penchant for Russian novels.
At one point, the woman who had experienced Moscow-type communism, incredulously comments on Yusuf having actually spent 10 years behind bars for socialism. Yusuf has no response, not even a tepid political slogan.
Nevertheless, despite political differences, the two characters, who are both damaged goods, are drawn to each other. Will these lovers be able to save one another?
Autumn includes Feza Caldiran’s cinematography of some beautiful scenery. There are also what appears to be archival footage of Turkish dissenters demonstrating and fighting against the police and government, scenes that represent the 30-something Yusuf’s activist, engaged youth.
At the Black Sea where they meet, Yusuf and Eka separately and together stand on a pier that juts out into the ocean like some of our SoCal piers, amidst rising swelling waves crashing about them, perhaps reminiscent of the 1925 Soviet revolutionary classic by Sergei Eisenstein, Battleship Potemkin. But now, the revolution is at low tide. Socialism has been dealt setbacks from the Blue Danube to the Pacific Ocean; indeed, since the end of the Mikhail Gorbachev era, the only place where socialism has arguably prospered is in Latin America and the Caribbean. Tellingly, Yusuf’s sole remaining friend at his mountainous Turkish village is named Mikhail, who, as portrayed by Serkan Keskin, has also tried to move on with his life but bitterly complains that now, even the dream of socialism has been taken away. Autumn ends with a long shot of a mountainous funeral procession bearing a red cloth draped coffin – perhaps symbolizing the death of the socialist dream of a workers paradise.
Autumn is an elegiac, poetic movie and one of the most moving moving pictures presented at 2009’s L.A. Film Festival. This thoughtful film deserves to be picked up by an American distributor so U.S. audiences can experience this beautiful Turkish work of art. Considering Autumn is Alper’s feature debut and that he is an auteur approximately only the same age as his lead character, this Turkish writer-director has a bright cinematic future ahead of him. Hopefully, so do political ideals of a just world.
.

















