
By Ed Rampell
Highlight of the mods: Controversy surrounds L.A. Opera’s third installment of Wagner’s Ring Cycle.
By Ed Rampell
Recently I was staying at Badrutt’s Palace, St. Moritz’s poshest hotel, and I rode a funicular on high to Muottas Muragl, which offers a breathtaking panorama of the Engadin Valley. Although it was still summer, the peaks of the Swiss Alps were powdered with snow, and the spectacular views stretched from Morteratsch Glacier to the almost 4,000 meter high Piz Palu -- referred to in Inglourious Basterds, which I’d coincidentally just seen – and to other majestic summits and the lakes sprawling below. But the awe-inspiring, jaw-dropping, eye-popping vistas didn’t put me in mind of Quentin Tarantino or Leni Riefenstahl, who’d starred in The White Hell of Piz Palu, G.W. Pabst’s 1929 mountain climbing epic that is ballyhooed on a movie marquee in Tarantino’s pseudo WWII flick.
Instead, as I hiked through this glorious ivory-topped Valhalla, I kept hearing the brassy Siegfried’s Motif rapturously played by the horn section in my psyche’s symphony. Upon returning home L.A. Opera had just the thing to feed my Wagnerian yen back in the City of the Angels (or rather of the Valkyries): Siegfried, the third installment of Richard Wagner’s The Ring of the Nibelungen.
So I flew to the premiere on wings of anticipation to see this continuation of the Ring Cycle, which had begun last February with Das Rheingold, followed by April’s production of Das Walkure. The $32 million productions have been the source of much tongue wagging amongst the “operati” (to coin a phrase), as director-designer Achim Freyer and the sorcerer’s apprentice, daughter and co-costume designer Amanda Freyer, acting in league with their co-conspirator lighting designer, Brian Gale, have wed a decidedly offbeat avante garde form to Wagner’s 19th century content. Yes, that all-seeing eye of the gods is back, a gigantic blue orb dangling above the stage, gazing at the players and audience like some sort of Asgardian Big Brother. To some opera traditionalists, the Freyers are lowbrow barbarians at the gates, storming a bastion of high art, tainting this rarefied realm with pop culture and outlandish sets and costumes. To these purists the Freyers’ Cycle is more cyclone, blowing hallowed traditions away, and is more highlight of the mods than twilight of the gods.
However, as this reviewer is not steeped in operatic conventions and has no emotional investment in them he is open to – and even relishes -- the outrageous inventiveness of the Freyers’ feverish, vivid imagination. Indeed, the Ring’s mythic quality invites outsized outrageousness: Siegfried (John Treleaven), a heroic Aryan youth, forges an Excalibur-type of super sword named Notung in order to slay the fearsome dragon Fafner (bass Eric Halfvarson reprises the role he’d played in Das Rheingold), and capture the eponymous Rhine gold and a magic ring. Then our man Siggy endeavors to rescue the Valkyrie Brunnhilde (soprano Linda Watson returns as the wronged winged woman warrior), last seen in Die Walkure’s grand finale, imprisoned within an inferno on a promontory, where she was banished for defying her father, head god Wotan (bass Vitalij Kowaljow, who likewise returns to this Nordic soap opera about the Wotan clan). True love ensues between the virginal Siegfried and Brunnhilde, who is around 20 years older and arguably the archetype of today’s so-called “cougars.”
Siegfried is full of Freudian subtexts: the phallic Notung, the vaginal ring, incest, Oedipal struggles with fathers, etc. Siegfried is fearless, until he encounters Brunnhilde, who makes him tremble and his heart pound. Treleaven plays the “chosen hero” as oafish if epic; Siegfried is the uber-ungrateful child, who clashes with Mime (tenor Graham Clark), the scheming dwarf who raised him after his Valkyrie mother died.
Norse and Germanic myths are the source material for Wagner’s Ring libretto, just as they were for Fritz Lang’s 1924 silent screen two-part adaptation of Die Nibelungen, Siegfried and Kriemhild’s Revenge. The notion of destiny – which Wotan warns nobody can change – suffuses the saga. As do the themes of militarism, struggle for world domination and will power -- the stuff Nazi dreams are made of. (The knowledgeable L.A. Times critic Mark Swed questioned presenting Siegfried so near the Jewish High Holy Days, Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement, but then again, the anti-Semitic Wagner had much to atone for, because when it came to Jews, the German composer was notoriously atonal.)
Treleaven wears a blonde fright wig and bodysuit that makes him look like a purplish Incredible Hulk, even as his light-sword has been unabashedly shoplifted from Star Wars. There is even some soft shoe in the Freyers’ offbeat version. But if this seems sacrilegious, consider that Wagner himself whimsically injected a note of levity in the second act, as Siegfried comically strives to find a musical theme so he can communicate with forest birds, which eventually trumpets his presence and becomes a leitmotif.
Conductor James Conlon wields a potent baton and Wagner’s music is nothing less than soul-stirring, an aural equivalent to the visual splendor of the Alps, where one feels closer to the gods. Operagoers – Freyer aficionados and gadflies alike – have a six month wait until the final installment of the Ring chimes in at L.A. Opera. But this is nothing compared to the 12-year-break Wagner took in between beginning and completing Siegfried. So, the next time someone complains about your procrastinating, just remind him/her of Richard Wagner’s pause, and ask them: “what’s the rush?” In any case, this critic predicts that Gotterdammerung will be well worth the goddamn wait.
Siegfried is being performed at L.A. Opera at the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion, 135 N. Grand Ave., on Sundays Oct. 4 and 11 at 2:00 p.m.; Wednesday Oct. 7 and Saturday Oct. 17 at 5:30 p.m. Please note the early performance times of Siegfried, which is four hours-plus long and has two intermissions. The final installment of the Ring Cycle, Gotterdammerung, will be performed April 3 – 25, 2010. L.A. Opera also plans to present the entire Ring Cycle again, May 29 – June 26, 2010. For more info: 213/972-8001; www.laopera.com.







